When you eat something a second time and it is no where near as good as the first time you tried it.
Billy: Why does food never taste as good as the first time you ever tried it, the second time is always worse!
Jim: Well thatâs an easy answer, itâs called the baconater effect; the second time is always worse. The first time I tried a baconator, orgasmic, the second time, mediocre at best⦠and thus you have the baconator effect.