cookie smeller

Another derogatory phrase to describe a gay man. Most older gay men have a look about their face that resembles a person who has just smelled a freshly batch of cookies. A sort of smug, satisfied look on their face that accompanies twinkly eyes and pursed lips that barely crack a smile.

Hag: Oh, look! There's Stephen. Is he gay?

Charles: Does he look like he just smelled a batch of cookies?

Hag: Yes he does!

Charles: He's gay and he;s a cookie smeller!