When you lather your hand(s) with butter and then proceed to masturbate.
I'm bored of just jacking off, I think I'll Nutter Butter tonight.
An act of accidently ejaculating on another mans genitalia durring female D.P.
I kicked some guys ass for giving me his Indiana Nutter Butter.
When you take a used condom and put a straw in it then put it back in a drink and offer it to someone.
i gave this girl my nutter-butter milkshake and she said it was very salty
Noun:
A person who sucks a straw full of peanut butter slam smoothy then inserts the straw in their partners ass and blows.
Jason you are being such a butt nutter.
Taking the Jizz from a fat person and making a sandwich out of it.
This Plumper Butter Nutter Taste really good with Tuna !!
Having the same mother but a different father
Yo wats up my brother from another nutter!!
General phrase to grab attention
Hey! How much nut could a nutter butter nut if a nutter butter could but nut?
Shut up Richard.