Craig: Yo, Alan, last night I was eating Stacy's ass so hard I got Satan's peanut butter all over my face.
Alan: Eww, dude, why are you telling me this? I told you I'm not into that kind of nasty stuff. Jeez.
The sexual act of pissing in an Amish person's ass, and churning it with your penis.
I went to Pennsylvania and had me an Amish Moon Butter last night.
The pissing into an Amish’s ass and then the churning.
Also a strain of weed
First defined by The Dooo
Got me some delicious Amish moon butter
When you piss into an Amish persons ass and then you churn it with your dick
I want some goddamn Amish Moon Butter.
The act if urinating in an amish persons rectal cavity and churning the urine with your penis, as if it were butter.
Hey man! I have a throbbing UTI because I just finished giving Debby the craziest Amish Moon Butter. My dick was literally churning my own piss in her ass! It was awesome!
The act of a man cumming on a womans sodden vagina.
Source: I just made this up.
Babe i want you to butter my jelly tonight and then we'll sleep in it.
That move was peanut butter bucket
These fries are peanut butter bucket