a new way of referring to sex, in which the penis butter is a penis and vagelly is vagina and you put the two together and sandwich them between two bodies
Chad: hey babe wanna have sex?
Vanessa: you mean make a penis butter and vagelly sandwich?
Describes the result of condomless (unprotected) sex and ejaculating inside of a vagina, creating a penis butter sandwich, which the perpetrator proceeds to eat after the act.
Man 1: "I ate a penis butter sandwich today."
Man 2: "Was it good?"
Man 1: "No, it needed some fruit."
White Negro: Wouja LIKE some Penis Butter!?!
Buttnigga: Um, sure, yea---
White Negro: I'MMACUMMON YURTITS!!!
the butter you make from penis milk.
i put some penis butter on my toast this morning.
Butter you make from penis milk
i spread penis butter on my toast this morning
When butter is applied to the crotch and the host allowing a dog to lick it off.
Wow, did Michael just have his dog lick the penis butter?
Noun: The white stuff that comes out of the male penis after ejaculation. Also known as seamen, cum and sperm.
Damn homie, Sarah swallowed all of my penis butter this morning. I was impressed.