The act of filling a girls asshole with peanut butter, then nutting in it repeatedly until her ass is stuck shut
Husband: I love nutter butters
Wife: Oh like the cookie?
Husband: No babe, grab the peanut butter and I’ll show you
When a girl shits on a man’s penis and he then precedes to bust a load into the girls booty
After Michael gave Allie a nutter butter, she went home to shower off the mixture of jizz and shit
When you send each other your nudes.
Hey dude wanna be Nutter Butters? I'll send mine first.
gooey stuff that comes out of your pee pee that makes girls pregnant
it also tastes very good it has a nice texture like butter
You got some flavourful nutter butter
When the male ejaculates during a prostate exam. When the male unintentionally busts a nut while at a doctors clinic getting a physical exam.
Bro! The last prostate exam I went to was crazy. As soon as the doctor was knuckles deep in my ass, I couldn't help but nutter butter. It was scary and exciting all at the same time.
after having anal sex with your partner/and or hooker...you spread their gaping asshole and stick your balls in it. after you pull out you make her suck your balls. hence... the nutter butter
hey jim i nutter buttered my gf last night and it was very buttery.
When you cum on a girl's stomach and rub it all around her body like lotion, like she's your bread you're buttering her with your nut.
"I nutter buttered my girlfriend last night and she has a really bad rash on her skin now"