It's the mucous mixed with spunk after your remove your junk from another orifice, animal or human.
Yo, I had some nutter butter on my jawn after I took it out of her ass.
When one homosexual male nuts on a stick of butter and puts the butter on toast and gives it to another homosexual man while having sex and eating it.
Daddy can you please do a Nutter Butter for me I want it so bad.
The act of inserting ones own balls into thine own or your lovers own butthole
Im gonna go home nutter butter myself and the cry myself to sleep
during anal sex, before you cum you pull out and proceed to turn her over and cum on her face and smear it, like spreading butter on toast
Yo man, Susan wanted to get wierd last night so I gave her the nutter butter
Nutter butter is a extremely thick cum from a male usually resembling sour cream in texture and density
His cum is totally Nutter butter
The stuff that come's out the booty
That dude has ton's of nutter butters
A nutter butter is almost like lube but made out of butter it is applied when you're about to have intercourse.
Wait let me apply some nutter butter.