When she smashes your balls so hard they turn into a fine paste, almost butter-like.
Guy 1: BROOOO WTF HAPPENED TO YOU!!!!
Guy 2: LAST NIGHT I GOT NUTTER BUTTERED SHIT BUSSIN!!!!!!!!!!!
The built up mixture of piss, nut and other bodily fluids under the foreskin of a penis. It can be enjoyed on toast with spices such as salt and paprika. Funnily enough, prime untouched Nutter Butter can be sold at a high price to certain individuals.
"Damn man, since I've become vegan, I can't have dairy and shit like that." "Yo you should try Nutter Butter dude, it can be grown easily by yourself and it isn't cruel to any animals!"
When 3 or more guys nut together. Usually to the same thing.
Hey Caleb and Adam want to start a nutter butter.
When you cover a girl in butter during sex
Damn i wish i could whisk the butter with her
basically telling someone to go die
Why dont you rub some butter on it?
Using a butter knife for sex or nudes very shiny when flash is on
Wow nice butter knife cut my butter