The act of taking a dump in between two Graham crackers, cumming on the poop, and making the other person eat it
My girlfriend was hungry and I was horny. So we compromised for a Cleveland Nutter Butter.
When you hike a 14er and are on your period and youβre quite gassy and you shart a little bit mixed with your period blood and all that sweaty moistness mixed together the pad you pull off is a raspberry nutter butter
When I got to the trailhead I slapped my raspberry nutter butter in some dudes windshield.
I was mortified when I saw my crushes dog running through camp carrying my raspberry nutter butter.
Primarily performed by a male but, given enough motivation, can be carried out by a female.
The act of verbally berating a subordinate while wearing tan, or khaki, pants with the testicles exposed through the zipper portion of the pants, where a generous dollop of peanut butter eagerly awaits a hungry canine.
Hey, did you see Chad going all Skippy Nutter Butter on Joe?
Yeah I saw, now all I can think about is how much I want a PB&J.
Once a man is close to ejaculation. He pulls out and sticks his penis in a tub of butter. Then inserts his penis in a woman's rectums and finishes.
I gave her a magical Peruvian nutter butter.
4π 3π
An act of accidently ejaculating on another mans genitalia durring female D.P.
I kicked some guys ass for giving me his Indiana Nutter Butter.
4π 5π
When you take a used condom and put a straw in it then put it back in a drink and offer it to someone.
i gave this girl my nutter-butter milkshake and she said it was very salty
5π 7π
Having someone complete the act of masturbation by pulling up and down on the forearm, while the male holds his own penis. This can be done with an infinite number of males. If and when someone ejaculates, it must be done onto a single Nutter Butter. The last person to orgasm must eat this cookie, thus becoming a Brudder for life.
Fraternity initiates; Sam, Dave, Diego, Bill, Steve, and Rod all pair off and begin the Dutch Rudder Nutter Butter Brudder challenge, Bill lost and now must eat the Nutter Butter. Bill is definitely a Brudder.