That uncomfortable sensation a heterosexual person gets when a member of the same sex touches them in a promiscuous way.
Joe: Hey man, don't touch my thigh like that, I get the Gay Tingles.
Earl: Sorry bro.
When people who are both apart of the LGBTQ+ community, when they think of similar things they’re toes tingle.
“Oh my god. Did you feel that toe tingle”
Toe tingle when gay people have telepathy
“I had the gay toe tingle”