The sensation one feels after taking an unbelievably massive shit. You will notice that your anus is exhausted and you experience pins and needles sensations like when your foot falls asleep. A side effect of the Holey Tingle is a tendency to not want to sit down but also need a nap.
My girlfriend took a dump so big that she said her butthole felt weird. I told her that's called the "Holey Tingle" otherwise known as an "Ass-gasm". She called me gross.