Re-Tickled The Toe

When someone just can't let a good joke rest and keep bringing it up in conversation, even though it's not as funny the second time around. It's like trying to tickle someone's toe twice – the surprise is gone, and it's just not as amusing.

So, at the party, Jake Re-tickled The Toe with that banana peel joke from earlier. Everyone kinda forced a laugh, but you could tell it was past its prime. Dude, let it go!