When you borrow something from someone and never return it or return it damaged and or not working.
Hitting your pregnant gf with a sack of russet potatoes in a Walmart to induce abortion then yelling “Luigi Time!”
I found out I was pregnant but he decided that pulling a Paul on me was the best way, problem solved.
Going to Waffle House or a similar establishment during the day or completely sober. This typically is a sign a person is completely insane or very old.
Jake: I saw John last night Pulling a Paul at Waffle House!
Gino: Hahaha, that's funny, but why were you at Waffle House last night?