When somebody goes on a streak of stutters while talking or chokes under pressure during a game.
Billy was doing great during his presentation until the Nutter butter stutters got to him.
The act of sticking your finger in your ass and pulling it out to find cum and nutty filled shit on your fingers. Then proceeding to stick them in your partners mouth
My dad gave me a raging new york nutter butter last night. or my grandmothers new york nutter butter taste the best
A man who never uses a condom and uses women as a semen dispenser.
That kid Aaron is a nutter butter, be careful you might get pregnant from him.
One of the most illicit drugs in the united states, not fucked around with by any pussy ass mother fuckers. Typically inserted rectally, it can also be snorted, but if you're shnifing anything you're probably already too pussy to try nutter butter. So far Nutter Butter is found predominantly in more metropolitan areas like NY and Cali, but it will probably make its way more inland soon.
"dude let's butt plug some nutter butter"
"my ass is so buttery right now"
The act of inserting ones own balls into thine own or your lovers own butthole
Im gonna go home nutter butter myself and the cry myself to sleep
The act of filling a girls asshole with peanut butter, then nutting in it repeatedly until her ass is stuck shut
Husband: I love nutter butters
Wife: Oh like the cookie?
Husband: No babe, grab the peanut butter and I’ll show you
When a girl shits on a man’s penis and he then precedes to bust a load into the girls booty
After Michael gave Allie a nutter butter, she went home to shower off the mixture of jizz and shit