When you just straight up shove a Nutter Butter® candy bar right up your ass while you scream out "Give me the cream!" and cum all over the floor.
"Nutter" refers to you cumming, "in the Butter" refers to anal stimulation with a Nutter Butter®
Oh man, Chad, I had the BEST Nutter in the Butter last night. You gotta try a Nutter in the Butter. You will not believe the sensation.
When a man gets a blow job with bread around his penis... he then ejaculates into the bread and makes the blow jobber eat it
-Swifty
She said she was hungry so she ate my Fluffer Nutter
When one is wiping after taking a poo and their finger pops through the toilet paper causing one to get shit on their fingers.
Get to ply tissue. I don't want to get a Nutter Finger.
A weak and lame individual. A nobody who doesn’t matter. Someone who is fake, a show boat who can’t deliver. All bluster
Look at this nutter butter with the gold chain
The opposite of Butter-Face. Everything looks nice, but nutter-butt. A girl with a pretty face and a great body, but has no booty.
I was hitting on this chick in my math class the other day, but I got turned off when she got up to leave. Her ass was ass flat as the seat she was sitting on. She's definitely on my list of nutter-butts to watch out for.
a upbeat nice mass of nut that wears a wraper that says nutter