Fanadequate

A "Fan" who is not fully a fanatic. One who enjoys and partakes of a cultural activity like sports, music, movies, religion, etc., but in moderation rather than to the extreme.

Example 1: Look at those fanadequates wearing our team's sportsball shirts? Why aren't they naked and painted yellow like the true fans!?

Example 2: These political/religious fanatequates sure are voicing their views in a conversational tone!