someone who is very attractive as in you'd date them
John- Would you date Kate?
Paul- Yeah she's a hotay.
11👍 2👎
It is a starkid reference from tgwdlm ted says it about someone who works at the coffee shop to Paul. Paul repeats it later only to be wrong about who 'the latte hotay' is some people call certain starkid members latte hotays
Example 1
Paul: you know the... latte hotay
Ted: that's not the latte hotay
Example 2
Starkid fan 1: Joey Richter is the latte hotay in starship
Starkid fan 2:i think he's the latte hotay in all the musicals
Starkid fan 1: well you're only a bit right